Kathy, you raise some poignant observations regarding the current situation in Afghanistan. The rebuilding process indeed relies heavily on the contributions of all citizens, including women, who have historically played crucial roles in their communities. It’s disheartening to witness the systemic suppression of women's rights, particularly in education and employment, which not only hinders individual potential but also stalls national progress.

The disparity in access to education between men and women reflects deeper societal issues that go beyond mere policy—it signals a fear of women’s empowerment and their potential to lead change. Afghan women writers and activists have articulated their frustration and resilience, and their voices are vital in the narrative of rebuilding a society.

Moreover, we must remember that we are all on the same side when it comes to supporting marginalized groups in every country. The right thing is clear, and we need to distinguish between incorrect practices and the needs of those affected. The ongoing challenges in Afghanistan cannot be separated from the context of the U.S. invasion, which has left the country in a state of devastation, lacking hope, and with crucial infrastructure, including healthcare and education, in ruins.

Upon departing, the U.S. has largely abandoned Afghanistan without providing the necessary support for rebuilding efforts—funding that has even been seized in the wake of the invasion. It is vital that the U.S., reevaluates its role and responsibilities, rather than shifting blame onto the victims of this complex situation. The voices outside Afghanistan often remain muted or fail to hold the U.S. accountable, perpetuating a cycle of silence and fear.

This unrelenting brutality affects not only Afghanistan but also the situation in Palestine, where the ongoing conflict has resulted in significant casualties among women and children. As of December 10, 2024, more than 46,000 individuals have been reported killed in the Israel–Hamas conflict, including 44,786 Palestinians and 1,706 Israelis, alongside at least 141 to 156 journalists and media personnel, 120 academics, and over 224 humanitarian aid workers, of whom 179 were employed by UNRWA. Furthermore, a UN report published in November 2024 highlighted that, based on verified data from multiple independent sources over a six-month period from November 2023 to April 2024, approximately 70% of Palestinian fatalities in Gaza were women and children. Compounding these issues, we witness daily reports of violence and suffering, with countless women and infants losing their lives, often shown live on television. Both crises are met with insufficient global outrage or action. The people of Afghanistan and Palestine are not merely statistics; they are individuals in urgent need of support and justice. It is essential to advocate for a united front that recognizes these tragic realities and actively works toward a hopeful future for all, regardless of their geographical location.